National Federation of the Blind
Committee on Automobile and Pedestrian Safety⁄Quiet Cars
Welcome to the Quiet Cars webpage sponsored by the National
Federation of the Blind (NFB). This page was created in response to
concerns among pedestrians, especially pedestrians who are blind,
about the growing trend for automobile manufacturers to design
extremely quiet vehicles. These vehicles pose a hazard to
pedestrians and cyclists, who need to be aware of approaching cars
that are out of their line of sight. Children and seniors are likely
to be most vulnerable. Quiet vehicles are highly problematic for
blind pedestrians, who depend on the sound emitted by cars in order
to travel safely and independently.
We all benefit from a less noisy environment, and we applaud the
efforts of the automotive industry to control noise pollution.
However, we feel strongly that the industry must take measures to
insure the safety of blind and sighted pedestrians. We believe that
vehicles can be designed to emit an inoffensive sound that will give
pedestrians the information they need. We call upon the automotive
industry to work with the NFB and other concerned organizations to
develop a solution to the pedestrian-safety problems which quiet cars
create.
On this page you will find links to published articles about quiet
cars and pedestrian safety. You can also read resolutions about
quiet cars that have been passed by the NFB and other organizations.
We will post news of relevant research and of policy within the auto
industry and the government. Finally, we offer a place where you can
describe your experiences dealing with quiet cars and share your
ideas on how these vehicles can be made pedestrian-safe. We are
eager to hear from you.
As they become more and more prevalent, quiet cars will compromise
the safety of millions of people throughout the world. By working
together concerned citizens can address the problems posed by these vehicles
and move toward viable solutions.
From NFB Websites:
Resolution 2006-05 - from the Article "2006 Resolutions of the National Federation of the Blind, Braille Monitor, ⁄September Issue
Stop, Look, and Listen: Quiet Vehicles and Pedestrian Safety
by Deborah Kent Stein ; from: The Braille Monitor, June 2005
Resolution 2003-05 Regarding Quiet Cars From the Braille Monitor, August⁄September, 2003
Minutes from the committee on quiet Cars and Pedestrian Safety, held July 2006 in Dallas, Texas
Quiet Car conference Summary, November 4, 2006
Blind Pedestrians Say Quiet Hybrids Pose Safety Threat
Published 2/13/2007; Outlet: The Wall Street Journal; By RAYMUND FLANDEZ
NPR Interviews - NFB on Quiet Cars Concerns - An interview with 1st Vice-President Dr. Fredric K. Schroeder on 2/23/2007.
We Want Cars That sound Like Cars by Daniel B. Frye
Braille Monitor November 2007
Download a sample of a suggested Quiet Cars Legislative Bill in MS Word
Washington Seminar 2008--Legislative Agenda--Quiet Cars Fact Sheet can be found here
Download "The Danger Posed by Silent Vehicles"A report delivered on 2/19/08in Geneva, by Dr. Marc Maurer
NFB continues work on issue of silent cars 2/21/2008 11:40:00 AM; From: Voice of the Nations Blind Blog
Remarks about the Problems Caused by Quiet Cars by Gary Wunder; Story appeared in the March 2008 issue of the Braille Monitor.
Download/Read "Legislative Alert" - Enhancement Act (H-5734), This is a summary of H-5734, the Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act,
introduced by Edolphus Towns (D-NY) and Cliff Stearns (R-FL). Please share
this information with groups and individuals, and encourage them to urge their
legislators to sponsor the bill.
More quiet cars in the news From: Voice of the Nations Blind BLOG, Posted: May 8, 2008
NFB - National Convention Highlights 2008 Here you will find links to the quiet Car presentation on Wednesday afternoon, July 2 during the General Session.
2008 Resolutions of the National Federation of the Blind --RESOLUTION 2008-02
Regarding Momentum Toward Solving the Quiet Cars Crisis
From The Association for Education and Rehabilitation of the Blind and Visually Impaired (AER)
the following documents were provided by AER. You can read or download these MS Word files to your computer.
Read the 1996 AER Resolution on Quiet Cars
Download the 1996 AER Resolution on Quiet Cars
Read the 2000 AER Resolution on Quiet Cars
Download the 2000 AER Resolution on Quiet Cars
Read the 2004 AER Resolution on Quiet Cars
Download the 2004 AER Resolution on Quiet Cars
Articles on the Web:
the next set of links will take you away from this page to other articles on the subject of "Quiet Cars".
Are Hybrid Cars Too Quiet to Be Safe for Pedestrians?
Pedestrians, used to loud engine noise, have less warning when a car powered by a hybrid or electric motor approaches, By Sarah Simpson, From: Scientific american
Making a noise for electric and hybrid vehicles 25 September 2008, Research from TheGreenCarWebsite.co.uk
NPR, (Interview) Here and Now Aired on 9/24/2008, "Sounds Like Silence" (Requires RealPlayer or compatible)
Hybrids vs. Pedestrians Up to Speed From Los Angeles Times, by Martin Zimmerman, Aug 20 2008
Hearing the Hybrids - Inside Bay Area
MediaNews editorial, Article Launched: 08/27/2008 11:02:03 PM PDT,
Making Hybrids Go Vroom, by Written by Peg Fong , Monday, 11 August 2008 , From: Ecogeek.com
Introducing the hybrid you can hear (so it won't run you over)
bBy Michael Savage, Thursday, 7 August 2008 , independent.co.uk
Play sample clip Requires flash player
A silent threat? By ANGELA CAVE, July 17, 2008, Herald Community, townnews.com
Hybrid cars may pose silent threat to the blind
By Rick Rojas, July 8, 2008; courier-journal
Advocates for blind seek street safety, want louder hybrids
By Ken Thomas, The Associated Press;
Article Last Updated: 06/23/2008 09:47:40 PM PDT
Amplifying Safety in Hybrid Cars From: NPR All Things Considered, aired: June 21, 2008
The next four links were provided by:
DisabilityNation, an Audio Magazine by and for People with Disabilities. Listen at
Disability Nation
Quiet Cars and the Pedestrian Problem Part I
Dial-up:
Part 1
Part 2
Quiet Cars and the Pedestrian Problem Part II
Broadband links:
Part 1
Part 2
Quiet hybrids may be danger to visually impaired Advocates want sound requirements for cars in order to prevent injuries. by David Shepardson / Detroit News Washington Bureau, Friday, June 20, 2008
Standford Pair Makes Electric Car Noisier--to help the blind - Inside Bay AreaBy Kristina Peterson
Palo Alto Daily News Article Created: 06/02/2008 09:00:02 PM PDT
COMMENTARY: Hybrids may be too quiet By DAVE DOWNEY - Staff Writer | Sunday, May 18, 2008 7:09 PM PDT
Oregon guide dogs trained to detect the silent danger of hybrid cars From: Oregonlive.com, Sunday, May 11, 2008, by WHITNEY MALKIN regonian Staff
Ea
Unobtrusive hybrid car ‘noise' being developed By Lawrence Rosenblum, From: The Journal Gazette, Published: May 8, 2008
Boy hit by hybrid car; mom says he didn't hear it coming From: kare11.com :: KARE 11 TV
Video clip from CNN - interview related to previous link
Are Hybrids Too Quiet?Wheels - Autos - New York Times BLOGUCR: Hybrid Cars Are Harder to Hear
(March 29, 2008)/
Blind pedestrians may not hear hybrid carsBy Martin Zimmerman, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
March 29, 2008
Pedestrian Safety: Hear it now?
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
EDITORIAL BOARD; February 29, 2008 4:24 p.m. PT
Toot, toot: Hybrid cars might be a bit too quiet
By MARGIE BOULE, Newhouse News Service; February 13, 2008
Are hybrids a silent danger? by COLLEEN FLANAGAN THE TRI-CITY NEWS, January 11, 2008
Blind walkers fear quiet hybrids by Edward L. Cardenas / The Detroit News; Monday, November 12, 2007
Listen to a presentation from the 2007 NFB of California Convention on "Quiet Cars" this is an audio file. To download and listen to the program on your computer, right click the link and select Save As.
Blind Protest Noiseless Hybrid
Peggy Lee, Reporting; Oct 3, 2007 5:46 pm US/Eastern
Blind People say Hybrid Cars, Nearly Silent at Slower Speeds, Pose Safety RiskNews Outlet: The Associated Press; Wednesday October 3, 6:47 am ET ; By Ben Nuckols, Associated Press Writer
Electric Cars and People who are Blind From: KCBS; (This is an audio file)
News Release: CASE: 07.00726, Serious Injury Collision: Vehicle vs. Pedestrian From: Chief of Police; January 5, 2007
Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader, get it here
Quieter hybrid cars raise worries for blind. By VERA OVANIN,
SUN MEDIA; London Free Press - Canada; Wed, August 8, 2007.
the Modesto Bee - Traffic changes challenge the Blind Hybrid vehicles and roundabouts make street crossings risky
By ROSALIO AHUMADA; August 01, 2007 ; From: The Modesto Bee
THESTAR.COM - Living - Hybrids too Quiet for Blind Pedestrians by Helen Henderson; July 16, 2007
Silent threat From: the Columbian; Friday, May 25, 2007; BY BRETT OPPEGAARD, Columbian staff writer
Hybrid cars silent, deadly, advocates for blind warn
By Peter Rice, Wednesday, May 23, 2007
from The Albuquerque Tribune
The Trouble with Clean Cars - top Story; By PAMELA WOOD, Staff Writer; Published February 07, 2007,
The Capital, Annapolis, Md.
Quieter Cars Put Blind Pedestrians At Risk by Sue Turner; from:
MMVI, CBS Broadcasting Inc.
the lead person in Acoustic Research and the Quiet Cars/Hybrid Car
Dr. Lawrence D. Rosenblum's Homepage
A website devoted to experimenting with sound perception and the "Quiet Car/Hybrid Car".
Audiovisual speech Web-Lab
THE FOLLOWING LINK IS THE RESULT OF RESEARCH AND THE FORMATION OF
Enhanced Vehicle Acoustics
EVA Sounds for NFB Here you will find sample recordings
The following link was sent to us as another source of development to resolve the concerns of Quiet Cars/Hybrids.
Step-Hear
Join the Mailing List:
A Public mailing list on "Quiet Cars" has been started. You can join the list in several different ways--the first is by going to the
QuietCars Info Page
Or, Subscribe using your favorite e-mail program to:
Subscribe to Quiet Cars. the e-mail address and subject fields are already filled in for you, just send it as a blank message.
Unsubscribe from Quiet Cars.
Homepage of the National Federation of the Blind
Voice of the Nations Blind
Kurzweil - National Federation of the Blind Reader Website
NCBYS National Center for Blind Youth in Science
NFB Link - Linking Individuals to a Network of Knowledge - Become a Mentor
Presidential Releases Now Available Here!
NFB - Braille Initiative
NFB - Free Cane Program
Committee Members:
Deborah Kent Stein, Chair, Chicago, Illinois
Bryan Bashin, Board member NFB of California
Doug C. Boone, President, D. Boone Consultants
Ron Gardner, Attorney at Law; President, NFB of Utah
Noel Nightingale, immediate past president, National Federation of the Blind of Washington
Barbara Pierce, Editor, Braille Monitor
Sumara Shakeel, M.A., NOMC, NFB of New Jersey
Gary Wunder, Secretary, National Federation of the Blind
Deborah Kent Stein, NFB-CAPS Chair
E-mail: Deborah Kent Stein, Chair
For Problems with this site E-mail:
Webmaster
Updated: Thursday, October 09, 2008
Copyright, © 2006-2008 by The National Federation of the Blind, Committee on Automobile and Pedestrian Safety, All Rights Reserved